| Platinum | Rhonda's Sweet Creations |
| Gold | Momma Vee's Kitchen |
| Silver | Insomnia Cookies |
| Bronze | Smallcakes |
| Top Pick | Crumbl Cookies - Columbia |
| Top Pick | Fluffybutt Cookies |
| Top Pick | Ginny and Coal Cookie Co |
| Top Pick | Hot Box Cookies |
| Top Pick | Pasta La Fata |
| Top Pick | Peggy Jean's Pies |